A repair estimate is the shop's written description of the job and what it should cost, and it is the paper you agree to before any work starts. Read it line by line while the car is still parked, because a question asked now is easy to settle and the same question asked after the work is done is much harder.
Parts and labor
Most of an estimate is parts and labor. Each part should appear as its own line with a name, a quantity and a price, and many shops also show a part number. If a line reads only “parts” or “miscellaneous” with one total, ask the shop to list what is in it.
Labor is usually charged at a standard time for the job, taken from a guide the shop uses, multiplied by its hourly rate, rather than by the minutes the mechanic actually spends. Ask what the rate is and how many hours each job is listed at. When two jobs share the same work, such as removing the same cover, that overlapping labor should not be charged twice.
- A separate line for each part, with its name
- The labor hours for each job and the hourly rate
- No single lump sum hiding several items
Shop supplies, diagnostic time and tax
Shop supplies cover small items used up on the job, such as rags, cleaners, grease and the disposal of old fluids. Many shops charge them as a small share of the labor, and the estimate should say how the charge is worked out. If it looks large for the job, ask what it covers.
Diagnostic time is the shop's charge for finding the fault, separate from fixing it. Ask whether it is a fixed charge or billed by the hour, and whether any of it comes off the bill if you go ahead with the repair there. Sales tax may apply to parts, labor or both, depending on your state, and belongs on its own line.
- How the shop supplies charge is worked out
- Whether diagnostic time is fixed or hourly
- Tax shown on its own line
Ask for it in writing, and approve it in writing
Ask for the estimate in writing before any work starts, on paper, by email or by text, so that you and the shop are looking at the same list. Many states require a written estimate when a customer asks for one, and some require it on every job. The written version also becomes your record of what you agreed to.
Before you sign, write or ask the shop to write a line saying that no extra work is to be done without your say-so. Many work orders already have a space for exactly this. Leave a number where you can be reached during the day, so a call about the car does not stall the job.
- The estimate in writing before work starts
- A line saying nothing extra without your say-so
- A number where the shop can reach you
When the estimate changes
Sometimes a mechanic finds more once the car is apart, such as a leaking seal behind the part being replaced. The shop should stop, call you and explain what it found before it goes any further. Ask for a revised estimate with the new lines and the new total, by email or text, before you agree.
You can turn down the extra work, or to approve some of it now and ask what the rest involves. Ask what happens if you decline, whether the car can be driven as it is and what putting it back together would cost. A revised estimate you agreed to in writing gives both sides the same record when the bill comes.
Checking the final bill
When you collect the car, put the final invoice next to the estimate you approved and compare them line by line. The parts, the labor hours and the total should agree, apart from any revision you signed off. Ask about any line that is new or larger before you pay, while the person who wrote the estimate is there.
The final invoice should also carry the odometer reading and the date, the parts fitted and the warranty the shop gives on its work. File it with your other service records once you are home. If the problem comes back, it is the paper that shows what was done and when.
- Compare the invoice and the estimate line by line
- Ask about any new line before paying
- File the invoice with your service records
The short version
- Get every estimate in writing before work begins
- Ask for each part and labor charge on its own line
- Agree that nothing extra is done without your say-so
- Compare the final bill with the estimate you approved
