When and how to get a second opinion

Two men looking at a car's engine with the hood open

A second opinion is another shop looking at the same car and the same complaint before you commit to a large or unexpected repair. It costs some time and usually a diagnostic charge, and in return it tells you whether two people who have seen the car agree on what it needs.

When a second opinion is worth asking for

Ask for one when the repair is large, when the diagnosis seems to jump straight to the most expensive answer, when the shop cannot explain the fault in plain words, or when several unrelated jobs appear on an estimate you expected to be small. It is also worth it after a repair that did not fix the problem.

A second opinion is not an accusation, and most shops expect one on a big job. You do not need to give a reason. Say you would like time to think it over, take the written estimate with you and pay for any diagnostic time you agreed to.

  • A large or unexpected repair
  • An explanation that does not make sense to you
  • Several new jobs on an estimate you expected to be small
  • A repair that did not fix the problem

How to describe the job to a second shop

Tell the second shop what you noticed, not what the first shop concluded. Describe the sound, smell or feel, when it happens and how long it has been going on, so the mechanic forms a view from the car rather than from someone else's finding. The repair planner on this site can help you write that description down.

Once the second shop has its own diagnosis, you can share the first estimate if you want to compare prices for the same work. Some owners prefer to share it from the start so the second shop can check a specific finding. Either way, keep both estimates in writing.

  • What you noticed, in your own words
  • When it happens and since when
  • The first estimate, once the second shop has looked

Paying for diagnostic time

Expect to pay the second shop for its diagnostic time, since finding a fault takes a mechanic's time and equipment whether or not you book the repair. Ask the charge, or how it is billed, when you call. A careful diagnosis you pay for tells you more than a quick look that ends in a guess.

If the first shop has already taken parts off, it may need to put the car back together before you can move it, and that labor is usually charged. Ask about this before you decline the repair. If the car is not safe to drive, arrange a tow rather than driving it across town.

Comparing like with like

Put the two estimates side by side and check that they describe the same repair. One may use new parts from the carmaker and the other aftermarket parts, one may include a related job the other left out, and the warranties on parts and work can differ. Ask each shop to explain any gap.

When the diagnoses disagree, ask each shop how it reached its view: a test result, a measurement or something it saw. A shop that can show you the worn part, the reading or the leak gives you more to go on than one that cannot. If the two still disagree, a specialist in that system can take a third look.

  • The same type of parts on both estimates
  • The same jobs included on each
  • The warranty on parts and labor from each shop
  • How each shop reached its diagnosis

The short version

  • Ask for a second opinion on large or unexpected repairs
  • Describe what you noticed, not the first shop's verdict
  • Expect to pay for a careful diagnosis
  • Check both estimates cover the same parts and work

About Horizon Driver

Horizon Driver explains car repairs and costs in plain words for owners. It does no repairs, quotes no prices and is connected to no shop, parts seller or carmaker. A mechanic who has seen your car decides what it needs.