New, aftermarket or used: choosing parts

A pile of used spark plugs

Most repairs can be done with more than one kind of part, and the choice changes the bill, the warranty and sometimes the fit. Knowing the options lets you ask which one the shop has priced and whether another would suit your car and your budget better.

New parts from the carmaker

Parts made for the carmaker and sold under its name are the kind the car was built with, often called original equipment. They are designed for that model, they come with the carmaker's parts warranty, and a dealer fits them by default. They usually cost more than the other options.

For some jobs they are the sensible choice: sensors for safety systems, electronic modules that must be programmed to the car, and repairs under the factory warranty. Ask the shop whether an aftermarket version of the part exists and whether it suits this job. On a newer car, ask whether the choice affects the warranty.

  • Designed for the model
  • Carry the carmaker's parts warranty
  • Often needed for programmed electronic parts

Aftermarket parts

Aftermarket parts are made by other companies to fit the car. Quality runs from equal to the carmaker's own to clearly worse, and the price varies with it. Many independent shops fit them by default, and for common wear items such as brake pads, filters, belts and wiper blades they are widely used.

Ask the shop which aftermarket part it has priced, why it chose that one and what warranty comes with it. A shop that buys from the same supplier every day can tell you how those parts have held up on other cars. Be wary of the lowest-priced option for brakes and steering, where fit and material matter most.

  • Which part the shop priced, and why
  • The warranty the parts maker gives
  • How it has held up on other cars

Rebuilt and used parts

A rebuilt or remanufactured part is a used part that has been taken apart, cleaned, fitted with new wear components and tested. Alternators, starters, transmissions and steering racks are often sold this way, usually with a warranty, and the old part goes back as a core. The estimate may show a core charge that is refunded when the old part is returned.

A used part comes from another car, usually through a salvage yard, and is sold as it is or with a short warranty. It can make sense for a body panel, a mirror or a piece of trim on an older car. Ask where it came from, how it was checked and what happens if it fails.

  • Rebuilt parts usually carry a warranty
  • A core charge refunded when the old part returns
  • Ask where a used part came from

What the parts warranty covers

A parts warranty usually covers the part itself if it fails, for a stated time or distance. It may or may not cover the labor to replace it again, and that labor is often the larger share of the bill. Ask whether the warranty covers parts only or parts and labor, and get the answer printed on the invoice.

Ask too whether the warranty is honored only by this shop or by others as well, which matters if a part fails far from home. Keep the invoice that names the part, since that paper is what a shop asks for when you request a repair under the warranty.

Seeing the parts that came off

Ask for the old parts back when you approve the estimate, not when you collect the car, since many shops discard them or send them back as cores soon after a job. Seeing a worn brake pad, a cracked belt or a leaking pump beside the new one shows you what was replaced and why. If a part is going back as a core, ask to see it first.

Many states give customers the right to ask for replaced parts, and many work orders carry a box to tick for it. You do not have to take them home. Looking at them at the counter, and asking the mechanic to point out the wear, is often enough.

  • Ask when you approve the estimate
  • Look at the wear before parts go back as cores
  • Tick the box on the work order if there is one

The short version

  • Ask which kind of part the estimate prices
  • Carmaker parts suit programmed and warranty repairs
  • Check whether the warranty covers labor as well as parts
  • Ask for the old parts back when you approve

About Horizon Driver

Horizon Driver explains car repairs and costs in plain words for owners. It does no repairs, quotes no prices and is connected to no shop, parts seller or carmaker. A mechanic who has seen your car decides what it needs.